FILES



Summary PDF: What is the evidence for strengths-based and trauma-informed approaches?

M&E | Track Resource Download

SHARE

What is the evidence for strengths-based and trauma-informed approaches?

Two impact and three suggestive studies indicate positive outcomes from strengths-based approaches.

Five studies were identified that have examined the outcomes of strengths-based approaches with refugee clients. These studies have addressed diverse outcomes including health, mental health, social support, English proficiency, and cultural and community connections.

Strengths-based approaches can take many forms and have shown promising results with newcomers of diverse genders, ages, national origins, and ethnicities.

One source of strong evidence, and three moderate to suggestive studies, indicate positive outcomes for trauma-informed programming with newcomers.

One systematic review, one randomized control trial, and two suggestive studies of trauma-informed programs for newcomers saw positive outcomes on almost all measures. Topics included education, parenting, and mental health.

Important elements of trauma-informed approaches include using facilitators with lived experience, facilitating peer support, transparency and trustworthiness of staff, and participant control of conversations.

Three sources of suggestive evidence indicate training providers in trauma-informed practice can increase the confidence of providers and help newcomers feel safe.

Providers reported increased knowledge of trauma in newcomer contexts and confidence in working with clients who have faced trauma after receiving training on trauma-informed approaches.

Studies that looked at client outcomes also indicated positive outcomes in areas of safety and security.

Post TitleStrength of EvidenceType of StudyDirection of Evidence
A systematic literature review to identify successful elements for financial education and counseling in groups.Positive impactSystematic reviewPositive impact
A systematic literature review to identify successful elements for financial education and counseling in groups.Positive impactSystematic reviewPositive impact
Financial outcomes of interventions designed to improve financial capability through individual development accounts: A systematic review.StrongSystematic reviewInconclusive or mixed impact
Interventions designed to improve financial capability: A systematic reviewStrongSystematic reviewNo evidence about impact
Financial literacy, financial education, and downstream financial behaviorsStrongMeta-analysisNo impact
Does financial education impact financial literacy and financial behavior, and if so, when?StrongMeta-analysisPositive impact
A systematic literature review to identify successful elements for financial education and counseling in groups.StrongSystematic reviewPositive impact
Integrating financial capability into employment services: Literature synthesisStrongSystematic reviewPositive impact
Financial education interventions targeting immigrants and children of immigrants: Results from a randomized control trialModerateImpact evaluationInconclusive or mixed impact
Trauma-informed Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF): A randomized controlled trial with a two-generation impactModerateImpact evaluationPositive impact
The effectiveness of smartphone apps in improving financial capability.ModerateImpact evaluationPositive impact
A case study of financial literacy and wellbeing of immigrants in Lloydminster, Canada.SuggestiveSuggestive evidenceNo evidence about impact

Websites and Databases Population Terms Methodology Terms Target Intervention Terms
PubMed

ASSIA

Social Services Abstracts

Social Work Abstracts

PsycInfo

Google Scholar

 

refugee

OR

immigrant

OR

“unaccompanied minor”

OR

asylee

OR

“temporary protected status”

OR

“victims of traffick*”

OR

“traffick* victims”

OR

T-Visa

OR

U-Visa

OR

Cuban

OR

Haitian

OR

Amerasian

 

evaluation

OR

impact

OR

program

OR

intervention

OR

policy

OR

project

OR

train*

OR

therapy

OR

treatment

OR

counseling

OR

workshop

OR

review

OR

meta-analysis

OR

synthesis

“financial coaching”

OR

“financial counseling”

OR

“financial education”

OR

“financial literacy”

OR

“financial products”

OR

“asset building”

OR

“individual development account”

OR

IDA