FILES



Summary PDF: What are the impacts of diversity, equity, and inclusion programs in nonprofit settings?

M&E | Track Resource Download
   Organizational Development
   

SHARE

What are the impacts of diversity, equity, and inclusion programs in nonprofit settings?

One source of strong evidence shows that diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) training can have significant short-term impacts on knowledge, attitudes, and awareness.

Seventeen of the 23 included studies reported statistically significant results on at least one of their measured outcomes, with knowledge, attitudes, or awareness being the most commonly reported. However, only six studies reported on longitudinal impacts (longer than one month), with three showing continued positive effects.

Three suggestive studies indicate that training for staff members may increase DEI awareness, but evidence of behavior change is lacking.

The three studies consistently reported high levels of satisfaction for their programs, as well as positive outcomes on knowledge and awareness of DEI concepts. Most of these outcomes were measured in the short term.

Behavior change was only measured through self-report, generally consisting of thoughts on being able to apply skills and knowledge from training. There is a gap in empirical evidence on whether staff training impacts observed behavior.

Two suggestive studies indicate that internship programs designed for minority groups can strengthen interest in an industry, but more robust institutional support is needed.

The majority of the internship participants reported being satisfied with their program and indicated a continued interest in pursuing a career within that field.

Institutional guidelines may prevent internship programs from reaching target demographics, or place undue pressure on minority/underrepresented groups to make the program work.

Post TitleStrength of EvidenceType of StudyDirection of Evidence
Evaluating equity: Assessing diversity efforts through a social justice lensInconclusive or mixed impactSuggestive evidenceInconclusive or mixed impact
Diversity, equity, and inclusion from the ground up: Evaluating the impact of a community-based DEI interventionPositive impactSuggestive evidencePositive impact
Impact of a multi-institutional initiative to engage students and early-stage scholars from underrepresented racial and ethnic minority groups in HIV research: The centers for AIDS research diversity, equity, and inclusion pathway initiativeInconclusive or mixed impactSuggestive evidenceInconclusive or mixed impact
Evaluation of a multipart implicit bias educational program designed for a non-profit organizationPositive impactSuggestive evidencePositive impact
Short-term outcomes of a diversity, equity, and inclusion institute for nursing facultyPositive impactSuggestive evidencePositive impact
A systematic review of diversity, equity, and inclusion and antiracism training studies: Findings and future directionsPositive impactSystematic reviewPositive impact
Exploring NSF-funded evaluators’ and principal investigators’ definitions and measurements of diversity, equity, and inclusionSuggestiveSuggestive evidenceN/A
The influence of board diversity, board diversity policies and practices, and board inclusion behaviors on nonprofit governance practicesSuggestiveSuggestive evidenceN/A
Value creation and value appropriation in public and nonprofit organizationsSuggestiveSuggestive evidenceN/A
Developing scientifically validated bias and diversity trainings that work: Empowering agents of change to reduce bias, create inclusion, and promote equitySuggestiveSuggestive evidenceN/A
Evaluating the organizational advancement of diversity, equity, and inclusion in extension educationSuggestiveSuggestive evidenceN/A
Building a framework for inclusion in health services research: Development of and pre-implementation faculty and staff attitudes toward the diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) plan at Mayo ClinicSuggestiveSuggestive evidenceN/A
Diversity initiative effectiveness: A typological theory of unintended consequencesSuggestiveSuggestive evidenceN/A
Diversity initiatives in the US workplace: A brief history, their intended and unintended consequencesSuggestiveSuggestive evidenceN/A

Websites and Databases  Population Terms  Methodology Terms  Target Intervention Terms  Target Outcome Terms 
EBSCOHost 

Google Scholar 

Elicit 

 

refugee 

OR 

immigrant 

OR 

“unaccompanied minor” 

OR 

asylee 

OR 

“temporary protected status” 

OR 

 “victims of traffick*”  

OR 

“traffick* victims” 

OR 

T-Visa 

OR 

U-Visa 

OR 

Cuban 

OR  

Haitian 

OR 

Amerasian 

 

evaluation  

OR  

impact 

OR 

program  

OR  

intervention  

OR 

policy  

OR  

project 

OR 

train* 

OR 

therapy 

OR 

treatment 

OR 

counseling 

OR  

workshop 

OR 

review  

OR 

meta-analysis 

OR 

synthesis 

“diversity equity and inclusion”  

OR  

DEI  

OR  

“gender equity diversity and inclusion”  

OR  

GEDI  

OR  

DEIJ  

OR  

“diversity equity inclusion and justice” 

OR  

DEIB  

OR  

“diversity equity inclusion and belonging” OR  

DI  

OR  

“diversity and inclusion”  

OR  

DIB  

OR  

“diversity inclusion and belonging” OR  

EDI  

OR  

“equality diversity and inclusion”  

OR  

DEIA  

OR  

“diversity equity inclusion and access”  

OR  

JEDI  

OR  

“justice equity diversity and inclusion” 

divers*  

OR  

access  

OR  

equality  

OR 

equity 

OR  

“implicit bias” 

OR  

“anti-racism”  

OR  

“structural racism”